
Written & Directed By: Chris Rock
Cinematography: Kira Kelly
Editor: Adam Dicterow
Cast: Rosalind Eleazar, Daniel Kaluuya,Chris Rock, Adam Driver, Anna Kendrick, Rich Sommer, Topher Grace, Amy Landecker, Alexandra Shipp, Kelli Garner, Tracie Thoms, Anthony Anderson, Ice-T, Necar Zadegan, Nicole Parker, Carlos Jacott
Years after her Hollywood breakthrough, a talented actress whose career has stalled fights for her second act.
I would compare MISTY GREEN to Jonah Hill’s Outcome, except this film makes that one look like a sunny little comedy about people discovering themselves. And that’s saying something.
Usually, filmmakers make some of their biggest mistakes with their first film. By the third time around, you’d hope they’ve worked out a few things. Unfortunately, MISTY GREEN, Chris Rock’s third directorial effort, doesn’t exactly inspire confidence.
After Top Five, which managed to balance comedy and drama with considerably more personality, I expected something a little more assured here. This time, Rock is clearly reaching for something more dramatic, even though the film is classified as a comedy-drama. The problem? There aren’t many laughs to be found, at least not intentionally And while I’m all for a filmmaker stepping outside their comfort zone, stepping outside your comfort zone doesn’t automatically mean you’ve found your artistic voice.
There has already been considerable criticism of the film’s portrayal of Black women and the entertainment industry. Quite frankly, I understand where that criticism comes from. It’s not necessarily the first time some of Rock’s material has invited questions about how he portrays women, and this film doesn’t exactly help his case.
First and foremost, Rosalind Eleazar who gives a surprisingly dynamic performance. She deserves considerably better material. There’s also something about her appearance that reminded me of Tracee Ellis Ross, to the point where I briefly wondered whether Ross had once been attached to the project. Regardless, Rosalind Eleazar makes an impression and gives the film more than it deserves.
The trouble is that this behind-the-scenes Hollywood story also wants to be a character study, but never quite figures out how to make those two things work together.
Our leading lady is struggling with her career, her personal relationships, her brother’s condition, and her own problems with alcohol and substance abuse. That’s plenty of material for an interesting character. But so much of what happens feels less like the natural progression of someone’s life and more like the screenplay checking off another unfortunate event.
Even her self-destructive behavior feels strangely disconnected. We never really understand what pleasure, comfort, or escape she gets from it. She simply does it because, apparently, the film needs another reason for her to have a bad day And there are plenty of those.
It would be one thing if this were a dark Hollywood satire with a character study running underneath it. Which would be expected and with Rick’s comedic mind and wit would truly shine and help. Instead, it plays like one long exercise in misery. Every time something remotely positive happens, another tragedy arrives to knock it down. Eventually, you start wondering whether the writer/director has a personal grudge against this woman or women in general.
Now, I can appreciate a filmmaker who refuses to take the easy route, sugarcoat reality, or deliver a convenient fairytale ending. Not every story needs a happy ending, and not every character deserves one. But there’s a difference between being honest and being unnecessarily cruel.
At times, Misty Green feels less like a critique of Hollywood and more like a poison-pen letter to its own leading character.
That becomes particularly frustrating with the Anna Kendrick supporting character, whose storyline feels shortchanged. There’s something potentially meaningful there, but the film barely gives it the attention or development needed to make an impact. It’s another example of an idea that seems to have been introduced without anyone quite knowing what to do with it.
The standout for me is Daniel Kaluuya, playing the protagonist’s bipolar brother. Making his first big-screen appearance in quite some time, Kaluuya is easily one of the film’s most compelling elements. He brings a presence and vulnerability that make you want to see more of him. Unfortunately, you also wish that performance had been placed in a considerably better movie.
He steals his scenes, even if the character occasionally feels less like a fully developed person and more like the film’s attempt at delivering a public service announcement.
And that’s really the problem with Misty Green. It has ideas. Quite a few, actually. The entertainment industry, aging actresses, mental health, addiction, complicated family relationships, loneliness, romance, and the indignities of trying to remain relevant in Hollywood. All worthwhile subjects. But they are practically fighting each other for screen time.
Rather than allowing a few of these ideas to breathe, the film insists that everything must be important, everything must have a message, and everyone must be having a terrible time. The result is a collection of storylines that frequently run into one another without adding up to a particularly satisfying whole.
Rock himself also appears as a romantic interest for the leading lady. Whether that’s a casting decision, a little extra star power to help sell the picture, or simply Rock wanting to give himself another acting opportunity, it’s an interesting choice.
There’s also an amusing irony in the romance. The two characters always seem to be almost ready for each other, just never quite at the same time. But the relationship never gets the attention it needs to become particularly compelling And perhaps it’s because Rock is playing the romantic lead that the film seems content to keep that aspect of the story on the back burner. With another actor, you might expect the audience to demand a little more chemistry, romance, or emotional payoff. Here, it almost feels like the film is asking us to accept that this is as good as it gets.
The character of Misty herself is another problem. We understand that caring for her brother takes an emotional toll, and that her career hasn’t exactly gone according to plan. She was once a respected actress, but now seems to be lingering around the fringes of Hollywood, with her personal relationships and extramarital affairs seemingly doing more to keep her afloat than her actual work. But her behavior is often so immature and erratic that it’s difficult to understand what makes her tick. Even during her dates with Rock’s character, he occasionally comes across less like a romantic partner and more like a concerned father trying to keep an eye on his daughter.
That’s not exactly the chemistry you want in a romantic drama.
And perhaps the biggest problem is that by the end, we never really develop much empathy for Misty. Whether she’s doing well or falling apart, whether she’s sober or under the influence, I found myself far more interested in the people around her and how they were affected by her behavior.
That’s a considerable problem when your film depends on getting us invested in its central character.
Even creativity, wise the film fails as why is the film she’s auditioning for the show us how great of an actress she is fresh a film that was made in the 1990s even though the film said in modern day and they changed the role that she’s playing from the sister of the main character to now aside the mother of the main character not to mention the dream role she wants to get in this film is the lead and a remake or reboot of Dreamgirls you’re telling me Chris Rock couldn’t just come up with fake audition slides that show her acting ability and maybe something deeper as her dream role instead of maybe just something the audience might recognize but will also see as ridiculous but maybe that’s the inside joke all along
Ultimately, MISTY GREEN feels like an album playing all the right notes but never quite getting in tune. There are flashes of something interesting, a few strong performances, and plenty of subjects worth exploring. It’s even polished enough to make you wonder how something with so much potential ended up feeling so underdeveloped.
For Chris Rock, this feels like a missed opportunity to show us more of his dramatic and artistic ambitions. I certainly wouldn’t discourage him from exploring that side of his filmmaking. But ambition and execution are two very different things.
Maybe the film is misguided. Maybe it simply needed another rewrite, a little restraint, and someone willing to tell Rock that not every bad thing that can happen to a character needs to happen in the same movie. Or perhaps he’s still at his best when comedy is driving the car and drama is allowed to ride shotgun.
Because Misty Green certainly has plenty of drama. It just could have used a little more life.
GRADE: D+









